| Grand Armory Brewing Nutter Your Business Peanut Butter stout, 4 Pack, 12 oz | 12 fl oz × 4 | 00653020928122 | meijer | 124 | derived |
| Sheep Dog Peanut Butter Whiskey (750 ml) | 750 ml | 00880040386704 | doordash | 97 | derived |
| 99 Brand 99 Proof Butterscotch Liqueur (50 ml) | 50 ml | 00806600101136 | doordash | 88 | derived |
| Sheep Dog Peanut Butter Whiskey Party Bucket (50 ml x 20 ct) | 1 L × 20 | 00880040386940 | doordash | 79 | derived |
| Ram's Point Peanut Butter Whiskey (50 ml) | 50 ml | 00880040387312 | doordash | 77 | derived |
| Liquid Death Feastables Peanut Butter Cup Liquid Death | 12 fl oz | 00840442201081 | vip | 74 | verified |
| Liquid Death Feastables Peanut Butter Cup Liquid Death | 19.2 fl oz | 00840442201302 | vip | 71 | verified |
| Frontera Wines Buttery Chardonnay Bottle Chile (1.5 L) | 1.5 L | 00827343141272 | doordash | 66 | derived |
| Ram's Point Peanut Butter Whiskey (750 ml) | 750 ml | 00880040387176 | doordash | 51 | derived |
| Lean Body Rtd Shake Chocolate Peanut Butter Lean Body | 14 fl oz | 00710779770553 | vip | 44 | verified |
| Spylt Peanut Butter Chocolate SPYLT | 11 fl oz | 00850045887100 | vip | 42 | verified |
| Carolan's Peanut Butter Cream Liqueur | | 00967490041572 | doordash | 36 | derived |
| DeKuyper Buttershots Butterscotch Schnapps Liqueur (1 L) | 1 L | 00806863192070 | doordash | 28 | derived |
| Sqrrl Peanut Butter Whiskey Bottle (750 ml) | 750 ml | 00806860280176 | doordash | 24 | derived |
| Martin House Peanut Butter Pretzel Stout Martin House Brewing Company | MHBC BLACK BALLOON 5.16GL | 00856927004764 | vip | 24 | verified |
| Martin House Peanut Butter Pretzel Stout Martin House Brewing Company | MHBC BLACK BALLOON 13.2GL | 00856927004757 | vip | 22 | verified |
| Ole Smoky Peanut Butter Tennessee Whiskey Bottle (50 ml) | 50 ml | 00853915008650 | doordash | 20 | verified |
| Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey Bottle (375 ml) | 375 ml | 30860265002154 | doordash | 19 | verified |
| Revel Stoke Nutcrusher Peanut Butter Whiskey Bottle (750 ml) | 750 ml | 00871160033784 | doordash | 18 | derived |
| DeKuyper Buttershots Butterscotch Schnapps Liqueur (375 ml) | 375 ml | 00806863196030 | doordash | 17 | derived |
| Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey Bottle (50 ml) | 50 ml | 60860265002421 | doordash | 17 | verified |
| Mr. Boston Butterscotch Schnapps Liqueur Bottle (1 L) | 1 L | 00890005122322 | doordash | 15 | derived |
| Gatorade Peanut Butter Chocolate Gatorade | 2.8 fl oz | 00052000010121 | vip | 14 | verified |
| PB&W Peanut Butter Flavored Whiskey Bottle (750 ml) | 750 ml | 00852045007304 | doordash | 14 | verified |
| Twisted Shotz Buttery Nipple Butterscotch Vodka PET Bottles (25 ml x 4 ct) | 100 ml × 4 | 07664270000004 | doordash | 14 | verified |
| Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey with Natural Flavors (100 ml) | 100 ml | 80860008141206 | doordash | 14 | verified |
| Muscle Milk Pro Peanut Butter Chocolate Muscle Milk | 14 fl oz | 00052000051179 | vip | 13 | verified |
| 99 Brand Butterscotch 99 Proof Schnapps Liqueur Bottles (50 ml x 12 ct) | 50 ml × 12 | 10080660010110 | doordash | 13 | verified |
| Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey Bottle (750 ml) | 750 ml | 20860265002409 | doordash | 13 | verified |
| Hiram Walker Butterscotch Schnapps Bottle (750 ml) | 750 ml | 00089540382074 | doordash | 12 | verified |
| Bread & Butter Wines Chardonnay Bottle California (750 ml) | 750 ml | 04000000125686 | doordash | 12 | verified |
| Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey Bottles (50 ml x 4 ct) | 200 ml × 4 | 00804320025060 | doordash | 11 | derived |
| Bread & Butter Chardonnay 2.25l Bread & Butter | 2.25 L | 00818051024322 | vip | 10 | verified |
| Dr. McGillicuddy's Butterscotch Liqueur (750 ml) | 750 ml | 00880040203094 | doordash | 10 | derived |
| Du Bouchett Butterscotch Schnapps Bottle (750 ml) | 750 ml | 00096749388325 | doordash | 9 | verified |
| Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey Bottle (750 ml) | 750 ml | 00602650024094 | doordash | 9 | derived |
| Bird Dog Peanut Butter Flavored 80 Proof Whiskey Bottle (750 ml) | 750 ml | 00812459015548 | doordash | 9 | verified |
| Back Forty Beer Co. Peanut Butter Porter Cans (12 oz x 4 ct) | 12 fl oz × 4 | 00851787002851 | doordash | 9 | verified |
| Whisper Creek Peanut Butter Chocolate Cream Liqueur Bottle (750 ml) | 750 ml | 00860335000324 | doordash | 9 | verified |
| DeKuyper Peanut Butter Liqueur Bottle (750 ml) | 750 ml | 00080686308010 | doordash | 8 | verified |
| Free Reign Imperial Wine Co. Buttery Chardonnay California V19 750ml EJW | 750 ml | 00085000039212 | vip | 8 | verified |
| Butternut Butternut Pinot Noir Organic California Butternut | 750 ml | 00818013014521 | vip | 8 | verified |
| Bread & Butter Cabernet 2.25l Bread & Butter | 2.25 L | 00818051024315 | vip | 8 | verified |
| Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey Bottle (750 ml) | 750 ml | 00849806001381 | doordash | 8 | verified |
| Tennessee Shine Co. Bread & Butter Pickle Chips Moonshine Bottle (750 ml) | 750 ml | 00850030657268 | doordash | 8 | verified |
| Hardywood Speculoos Cookie Butter Beer Hardywood Park Craft Brewery | 16 fl oz | 00850031276017 | vip | 8 | verified |
| Jam Butter Chardonnay Butter | 375 ml | 00853706002775 | vip | 8 | verified |
| 99 Brand Peanut Butter 99 Proof Whiskey Bottles (50 ml x 12 ct) | 50 ml × 12 | 10088004038554 | doordash | 8 | verified |
| Ole Smoky Butter Pecan Moonshine Jars (50 ml x 6 ct) | 50 ml × 6 | 10853915008299 | doordash | 8 | verified |
| Wise Buttered Popcorn Wise | 6 fl oz | 00041262274532 | vip | 7 | verified |